Can a Trucking Company Destroy Evidence After an Accident?

Evidence from a commercial truck accident may begin disappearing long before an injury claim ever reaches court. However, once a company has a legal duty to preserve material it knows may be relevant to anticipated litigation, destroying that evidence is not something it can freely do.

That duty matters because electronic logging devices (ELDs), engine-control data, and dashcam footage often help with explaining how a collision happened. Preserving those materials early may determine whether the parties are later able to reconstruct the truck’s operation and evaluate fault.

What Is Spoliation of Evidence in a Truck Accident?

State law generally treats spoliation as the failure to preserve relevant evidence when a party had a duty to do so. In Brookshire Brothers, Ltd. v. Aldridge, the Texas Supreme Court tied the duty to preserve to the moment a party first has reason to anticipate litigation over evidence that bears on the dispute. A trucking company may therefore need to suspend its ordinary destruction practices for records tied to a serious collision.

How Long Must Trucking Companies Keep ELD and Driver Log Data?

Under federal rules, a motor carrier must keep each driver’s record of duty status, together with the supporting paperwork, for no less than six months. Under 49 Code of Federal Regulations § 395.8, the same regulation also prohibits tampering with an ELD so that it fails to record or retain required information. Black box data or dashcams, which can provide other types of evidence in these cases, are governed by different schedules so the preservation duty may matter before any ordinary retention period expires.

How a Spoliation Letter Protects Truck Accident Evidence

A spoliation letter puts the trucking company on formal notice to preserve specific records connected to the collision rather than relying on a broad, vague request. Early notice also creates a clearer record of when the company learned that particular materials were relevant to a potential claim.

Talk to a Lawyer at KGS Law PLLC About Trucking Company Evidence After an Accident

Destruction does not automatically decide liability. Texas courts instead weigh whether a preservation duty existed and whether the loss caused real prejudice, and serious misconduct can support a jury instruction allowing an adverse inference. Once preservation obligations attach, destroying relevant material may carry real consequences. KGS Law PLLC could work quickly to identify evidence and send a focused preservation notice. Contact our team to discuss the possible destruction of trucking company evidence after an accident.